“The Magicians”: Harry Potter for Clever People

Lev Grossman’s “The Magicians” is often referred to as Harry Potter for adults. Brakebills University is like a Hogwarts grad-school hidden in a pocket dimension in New York City. Quentin Coldwater is a super-nerd who escaped clinical depression by reading Narnia-esque children’s books. Then magic turns out to be real but not very kid-friendly. “Magic doesn’t come from talent,” his friend explains. “It comes from pain.”
All the main characters have different kinds of pain. Penny is a psychic who does “a little or a lot of self-medicating” to silence the screaming voices. Alice is a nerd who is smarter and therefore more powerful than everyone else, and almost everyone hates her for it. Julia is certain she has magical potential but is forced to find magic on the streets like a drug addict. These are the good kind of mature things the show does. All the foul language, sex, and violence are less cool for Christians.
The show has a mysterious web of subplots running throughout, many of them hinted at early on, which messes with the pacing. The plot is still easy enough to follow, however, and the explanations for these mysteries are very satisfying. When I watched the season again, I understood all the cryptic references, and some of the subplots became even more significant. The first few episodes may seem rushed, but there turns out to be a very clever reason for that.
One problem I do have with this show is how grim its mature atmosphere sometimes gets. People dying of sickness and gruesome attacks would be expected, but the romantic relationships bring a lot of angst as well. Everyone spends so much time looking sad, it’s easy to forget that we’re watching a show about magical people and not “A Series of Unfortunate Events.”
Season 2 promises to further explore the pure magic of this universe. It’s sure to be grim, subverting fantasy tropes all over the place, but I can hope there will be less angst. Even if “The Magicians” is for adults, it’s also supposed to appeal to the kid in all of us. As an added bonus, the show is intelligently done, further rewarding viewers who pay attention.

Any thoughts about this show? Let’s Connect.

One way to connect is Ask Us Questions!
If you have a question about any fandom Isaac or I have written about, any fandom we haven’t written about that you’d like to read about, or anything Correlation-related, ask away in comments, on Twitter, or the Facebook page.
If I get a question this weekend, I’ll try to answer it for next week’s post.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s