Strap in, folks. This is a long one.
Round 1
The Lion King vs Tarzan: The Lion King
Arth broke down the Christian themes to be found in The Lion King. Tarzan, on the other hand, is a bit too Darwinian for this contest.
The Princess and the Frog vs Lilo & Stitch: Lilo & Stitch
Aliens are better than voodoo.
Tangled vs Big Hero 6: Tangled
It’s a prodigal princess story.
Frozen vs Moana: Moana
I know, Polynesian gods. But it’s also about having the courage to do what you’ve been called to do.
Aladdin vs Hercules: Aladdin
Magical lessons about material possessions are better than polytheistic gods and idols.
The Little Mermaid vs Pocahontas: The Little Mermaid
In one, a non-Christian girl convinces a Christian man to talk to trees for guidance. In the other, there’s a witch, but she’s definitely evil.
Mulan vs Zootopia: Zootopia
A parable of racism is better than Eastern religion ancestral spirits.
Beauty and the Beast vs The Nightmare before Christmas: Beauty and the Beast
I haven’t seen Nightmare before Christmas (I know, shame on me), but I’m just going to assume the movie with a living skeleton protagonist has something not-cool for Christians in it.
Up vs Brave: Up
Magic again.
Toy Story vs Toy Story 2: Toy Story 2
The second movie expands on the Christian-compatible themes set up in the first one.
Coco vs Cars 2: Cars 2
Yeah, I know. But I haven’t seen Coco. All I know is it’s about a version of the afterlife that is definitely not the Christian one.
Toy Story 3 vs The Good Dinosaur: Toy Story 3
The trailer alone disqualifies the Good Dinosaur. Millions of years a-no!
Ratatouille vs A Bug’s Life: Ratatouille
Honestly, I have no real argument for this one. Ratatouille is just better.
Finding Nemo vs Inside Out: Finding Nemo
“Look around you! We’re inside a whale! We’re going to be digested! Do you know what that means?”
“Of course I do! Digestion runs very deep in my family!”
Love that movie.
Monsters Inc vs Cars: Monsters Inc
Childlike faith and unconditional love cast out fear.
The Incredibles vs Wall-E: Wall-E
Watch this.
Round 2
The Lion King vs Lilo & Stitch: The Lion King
Tangled vs Moana: Moana
Aladdin vs The Little Mermaid: The Little Mermaid
Zootopia vs Beauty and the Beast: Zootopia
Up vs Toy Story 2: Toy Story 2
Cars 2 vs Toy Story 3: Toy Story 3
Ratatouille vs Finding Nemo: Finding Nemo
Monsters Inc vs Wall-E: Wall-E
Round 3
The Lion King vs Moana: The Lion King
The Little Mermaid vs Zootopia: Zootopia
Toy Story 2 vs Toy Story 3: Toy Story 2
Finding Nemo vs Wall-E: Wall-E
Round 4
The Lion King vs Zootopia: The Lion King
Toy Story 2 vs Wall-E: Toy Story 2
Final Round: The Lion King vs Toy Story 2
Toy Story 2 is the most Christian-compatible of all the Pixar movies, but the spiritual parallels in the Lion King are clearer.
So the winner is The Lion King! Woot.
Everyone else is, of course, welcome to share their brackets. If you base it on personal preference it’ll probably turn out different from one based on a Christian worldview.