Introduction
I identify as a writer by trade and storyteller by hobby. This is shorthand for I’m an unpublished fiction (specifically sci-fi/fantasy) writer who currently has a B.S. in English – Writing. One of the biggest struggles I’ve had with being a fiction writer, especially this year, is the question of whether or not the writing of fiction is the same as being a liar.
The answer to which I have come is a shaky no. Lies are meant to conceal the truth; fiction is meant to entertain. While both fall apart at the first glimpse of truth, their intentions could not be further from each other. I lean towards science-fiction and fantasy even stronger because of this question, for they are the least-believable (or most easily disproved) of the fictions.
That said, I’m here to discuss a story so far from the truth that it can only be classed as a work of fiction. That’s right: I’m finally doing a review on Good Omens.
SPOILERS AHEAD, by the way. (For both the book and the series. Yes, I read the book. What did you expect?)
The story centers primarily around Aziraphale, an angel played by Michael Sheen, and Crowley, a demon played by David Tennant, who are forced to work together to avert the apocalypse when the latter is tasked with delivering the Antichrist. Of course, things go awry when they misplace the Antichrist, and it’s up to them (and a couple dozen other characters along the way) to find this child before his powers manifest and the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse arrive to his side and Armageddon begins.
The End Times
In order to properly discuss this, I have to open with how the show and book ends: the apocalypse gets cancelled. The Antichrist, an eleven-year-old boy named Adam, continues living as…well, an eleven-year-old boy. Aziraphale keeps running his book store and Crowley keeps driving his Bentley.
I bring this up right away because this is one of the points in favor of the show. Of course it’s an apocalypse that doesn’t line up with Revelations; it doesn’t end up being the one in Revelations.
(Though, I should mention that if it was, it looks like the writers ran with the Post-Tribulation/Pre-Millennium interpretation, which is a stark contrast to the more traditional Pre-Trib/Pre-Mill popularized by Left Behind and most textbooks.)
That said, I can’t say if it gets a pass because…say…there’s no appearance from the Two Witnesses (Revelation 11). Of course they wouldn’t show up because this isn’t the real deal. But they play it like it’s going to be the real deal and nobody notices their absence.
All this to say, I can’t really speak for the end-times stuff because eschatology isn’t my strong suit.
Then again, neither are angels, demons, Heaven, and Hell, but I’m gonna spend the rest of this post talking about how they were portrayed.
The Heavenly Forces and the Hordes of Hell
I think it’s a bit of a knee-jerk reaction of mine that started with Screwtape Letters and kept going, but I don’t entirely agree with the idea of Heaven and Hell being businesses run by angels and demons respectively. I always thought of them more as they are depicted in Scripture–as Kingdoms run by God in Heaven and Satan in…wherever the demons operate. We’ll call it “Downstairs”. (Because I don’t think it’s Hell; as that’s their final place of torment.)
So, right out the gate, we have Aziraphale and Crowley living in a kind of corporate ladder. Aziraphale takes orders from Gabriel and Michael (who is a woman for some reason), and Crowley gives presentations Downstairs, complete with slides. God never shows up in the book; the closest Aziraphale gets to is an angel named Metatron. In the series, God fills the role of narrator, played by a woman.
[through gritted teeth] Nice to see feminist theology is catching on. Which part of “Father, Son, and Holy Spirit” did we miss, again?
Speaking of, one of the key differences between the book and the series are two added segments. The first in Episode 3, where the first half of the episode is dedicated to showing Aziraphale and Crowley in a montage of “Times we’ve met up through history,” including three stops in the Bible (Eden, Noah’s Ark, and Golgotha). The first is addressed in the book, and it and the third are the most problematic.
In this version, Satan did no tempting. Good Omens claims it was Crowley in the garden as the snake and in the desert tempting Jesus. That…just…no.
Also, Aziraphale was the angel that guarded the gate of Eden with a flaming sword. Which–in this version–he gave to Adam and Eve to defend themselves from all the suddenly carnivorous animals. Again, no.
Also, at Golgotha, neither of them recognize Jesus as the Son of God, despite the entire hosts of Heaven and multiple demons doing so in the Gospels. For this, I need a word stronger than no that I can write on this Christian blog.
The second added segment comes in Episode 6 at the very end. The plot is resolved and everything’s tied up, but…wait…what’s this? Angels drag Aziraphale to Heaven and Crowley to Hell, and it’s revealed that the two businesses made a deal with each other to help each other execute the angel and demon for their betrayal.
Which…worries me. Both that Amazon will pick the show up for a second season that deals with that dynamic way too heavily.
Oh, and one other thing, where do we keep getting the idea that the Antichrist is the physical child of Satan? Because I’m pretty sure that doesn’t come up in any end times prophecies. I always interpreted him as a global leader of some sort who persecutes Christians in droves.
Conclusion
Honestly, I could do an episode-by-episode analysis of this show, but I don’t think it’s worth the time. The show adds a lot of stuff simply not in the book. And everything added just causes more theological issues. The lack of research–which is what I chalk this up to–disappoints me. Not to the point of drafting an enraged spoken word piece about it, but enough to write a lengthy blog post on it.
And sure, the book wasn’t a perfect spectacle of accurate theology, but…
…I…I don’t think I’ve really said this on the blog yet…but…
The book was better.
5.5/10 ~ Amazon had better not pick this up for a second season, I swear.
Let’s Connect!
@Isaac_Trenti
@CorrelationBlog
And in the comments below!